CAPITAL BUDGETING DECISION MAKING

 

 

CAPITAL BUDGETING DECISION MAKING

  1. 1.      Table of contents:

1.    Table of contents: 2

2.     Introduction: 3

3.    Capital budgeting technique: 4

4.    Analysis: 5

5.     Assumptions: 8

6.    Conclusion: 9


 

  1. 2.      Introduction:

Change is something that is required in each and everything that exists today. If the business does not change with the changing demands of the customer, then it will decay and terminate.

It was with this thought that the management of Goldstar Corporation thought of introducing a new line of products of dairy products. This would require an extension of the wing of the whole new production and supply chain.

This report aims at discussing the various outflows and the inflows that the new line of product will entail.

 

 

  1. 3.      Capital budgeting technique:

Capital budgeting is very crucial when it comes to making the decisions with relation to the acceptance of products.

Capital budgeting is the technique whereby the decision of whether to take an investment or not depends. The investment decisions that involve a considerable period of time in order to mature have to be based upon the returns that would be derived from the investment. Unless and until, the project has been accepted for social reasons sonly, then it should be accepted only if it entails positive cash flows over the period of time.

It is good to know the amount of the present value that the project would provide to the company. (Fao.org 2014)

The following are the techniques that have been used for the evaluation of the new line of the products:

  1. 1.      Net present value:

This is the technique in which the present value of the cash inflows and cash outflows are calculated. Only, if the net present value is positive, then the project must be accepted, otherwise not.

In the given case, the following is the NPV:

Net present value           -39,04,397.56

 

  1. 2.      Internal rate of return:

The internal rate of return is the return on an investment or a project that is the annualised effective compounded rate of return. In other words, it is the discount rate that makes the net present value of all the cash flows from the particular investment to 0.

(Princeton.edu 2014)

When the internal rate of return is calculated for the new line of product, then the following rate of return is calculated:

 

Internal rate of return         5.793%

 


 

  1. 4.      Analysis:

The following are the calculated values:

Statement of incremental cash flows: (Amounts in $)
 Particulars  Workings  Amount  Year  PV factor  Present value  
             
 Cash inflows:            
             
 Incremental annual sales value:            
 Year 1      2,50,000.00        1.00     0.89286      2,23,214.25         2,50,000.00
 Year 2      2,50,000.00        2.00     0.79719      1,99,298.25         2,50,000.00
 Year 3      2,50,000.00        3.00     0.71178      1,77,945.00         2,50,000.00
 Decrease in the overall costs      1,50,000.00           –     1.00000      1,50,000.00         1,50,000.00
 Decrease in the cost due to new dairy products    15,50,000.00           –     1.00000    15,50,000.00       15,50,000.00
 Increase in the creditors         30,000.00           –     1.00000         30,000.00            30,000.00
 Tax savings in depreciation:                              –  
 Depreciation     1,31,775.00    1,88,250.00        1.00     0.89286      1,68,080.33          -45,000.00
 Depreciation     1,31,775.00    1,88,250.00        2.00     0.79719      1,50,071.58          -45,000.00
 Depreciation     1,31,775.00    1,88,250.00        3.00     0.71178      1,33,992.59          -45,000.00
 Sales of old machine         40,000.00           –     1.00000         40,000.00            40,000.00
 Initial investment:                              –  
 Stock         60,000.00        3.00     0.71178         42,706.80            60,000.00
 Debtors         40,000.00        3.00     0.71178         28,471.20            40,000.00
 Salvage value of the new machine      3,00,000.00        3.00     0.71178      2,13,534.00         3,00,000.00
             
 Total cash inflows            31,07,314.00  
             
 Cash outflows:            
             
 Initial investment:            
 Stock         60,000.00           –     1.00000         60,000.00          -60,000.00
 Debtors         40,000.00           –     1.00000         40,000.00          -40,000.00
 Cost of the machine    15,55,000.00           –     1.00000    15,55,000.00     -15,55,000.00
 Cost of the samples distributed         30,000.00           –     1.00000         30,000.00          -30,000.00
 Increase in the operating costs    17,00,000.00        1.00     0.89286    15,17,856.90     -15,17,865.90
 Increase in the operating costs    17,00,000.00        2.00     0.79719    13,55,228.10     -13,55,228.10
 Increase in the operating costs    17,00,000.00        3.00     0.71178    12,10,026.00     -12,10,026.00
 Training costs         40,000.00           –     1.00000         40,000.00          -40,000.00
 Additional training costs         25,000.00           –     1.00000         25,000.00          -25,000.00
           
 Total cash outflows            58,33,111.00     -58,33,111.00
           
 Net present value           -39,04,397.56
           
Internal rate of return         5.793%

 

From the analysis of the above case, we find that the following values:

Net present value           -39,04,397.56
           
Internal rate of return         5.793%

 

Both the net present value and the internal rate of return are lower.

The NPV is negative, this means that if the company accepts the launch of this new product line, then the company will only end up in paying more out of its pockets.

Further, the IRR is also lower. Only if the IRR exceeds the cost of capital, then only it would add value to the company.

Keeping in mind the above scenario, the project should not be accepted.

Working note:

Cost of the new machine:
Particulars Amounts in $
   
Parts and accessories       12,00,000
Transportation cost              5,000
Import duty         1,50,000
Installation         2,00,000
   
   
Total cost of the new machine       15,55,000
   

 


 

  1. 5.      Assumptions:

 

  1. The cost that has been incurred in respect of the market survey of $45,000 would be termed as sunk cost since, the obligation of it has already been decided.
  2. The cost that has been incurred in respect of the old machine of $240,000 would be termed as sunk cost since, the obligation of it has already been decided.
  3. It has been assumed that the new line of products would remain operational only for 3 years.

 

 

  1. 6.      Conclusion:

From the basis of the above, it could be said that the new line of product must not be accepted. If it is accepted, it will only cast a burden on the pockets of the company.


 

  1. 7.      References:

Fao.org, 2014. ‘Chapter 6 – Investment Decisions – Capital Budgeting’. http://www.fao.org/docrep/w4343e/w4343e07.htm.

Princeton.edu, 2014. ‘Internal Rate of Return’. http://www.princeton.edu/~achaney/tmve/wiki100k/docs/Internal_rate_of_return.html.

 

WACC  

12%

Statement of incremental cash flows:

(Amounts in $)

 Particulars

 Workings

 Amount

 Year

 PV factor

 Present value

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 Cash inflows:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Cost of the new machine:

             
 Incremental annual sales value:            
 Year 1       250,000.00        1.00     0.89286       223,214.25          250,000.00

Particulars

Amounts in $

 Year 2       250,000.00        2.00     0.79719       199,298.25          250,000.00    
 Year 3       250,000.00        3.00     0.71178       177,945.00          250,000.00 Parts and accessories       1,150,000
 Decrease in the overall costs       150,000.00           –     1.00000       150,000.00          150,000.00 Transportation cost            50,000
 Decrease in the cost due to new diary products    1,550,000.00           –     1.00000    1,550,000.00       1,550,000.00 Import duty          150,000
 Increase in the creditors         30,000.00           –     1.00000         30,000.00            30,000.00 Installation          200,000
 Tax savings in depreciation:                              –      
 Depreciation      131,250.00     187,500.00        1.00     0.89286       167,410.69          -45,000.00    
 Depreciation      131,250.00     187,500.00        2.00     0.79719       149,473.69          -45,000.00 Total cost of the new machine       1,550,000
 Depreciation      131,250.00     187,500.00        3.00     0.71178       133,458.75          -45,000.00    
 Sales of old machine         40,000.00           –     1.00000         40,000.00            40,000.00
 Initial investment:                              –  
 Stock         60,000.00        3.00     0.71178         42,706.80            60,000.00
 Debtors         40,000.00        3.00     0.71178         28,471.20            40,000.00
 Salvage value of the new machine       300,000.00        3.00     0.71178       213,534.00          300,000.00
             
 Total cash inflows            3,105,512.63  
             
 Cash outflows:            
             
 Initial investment:            
 Stock         60,000.00           –     1.00000         60,000.00          -60,000.00
 Debtors         40,000.00           –     1.00000         40,000.00          -40,000.00
 Cost of the machine    1,550,000.00           –     1.00000    1,550,000.00     -1,555,000.00
 Cost of the samples distributed         30,000.00           –     1.00000         30,000.00          -30,000.00
 Increase in the operating costs    1,700,000.00        1.00     0.89286    1,517,856.90     -1,517,865.90
 Increase in the operating costs    1,700,000.00        2.00     0.79719    1,355,228.10     -1,355,228.10
 Increase in the operating costs    1,700,000.00        3.00     0.71178    1,210,026.00     -1,210,026.00
 Training costs         40,000.00           –     1.00000         40,000.00          -40,000.00
 Additional training costs         25,000.00           –     1.00000         25,000.00          -25,000.00
           
 Total cash outflows            5,828,111.00     -5,833,111.00
           
 Net present value           -3,905,310.19
           
Internal rate of return        

5.793%